#17 on the leaderboard
Read 35 trader-submitted reviews of SurgeTrader, averaging 3.8 out of 5 — covering the SurgeTrader evaluation challenge, payout speed, drawdown and consistency rules, trading platforms, and support.
Showing 1–30 of 35, newest first · page 1 of 2
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Used the cTrader option and had no real complaints. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Ran it on MT5 and execution was fine for my style. Every ticket I opened got a real answer in under a day. Would sign up for another account.
Passed the challenge but the ride wasn't as smooth as I expected. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. Support replies are slow and often copy-paste. Worth it if you go in with your eyes open.
I've been trading a SurgeTrader account for a couple of months and it's been a mixed bag. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. I got breached by a consistency rule that isn't obvious until you read the fine print. Do your own research before you buy a challenge.
Wanted to like SurgeTrader but the experience went downhill after a while. First withdrawal was fine, the second one they kept asking for more documents. Ran it on MT5 and execution was fine for my style. Be careful and screenshot everything.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. No regrets so far.
Cleared the evaluation with SurgeTrader in a few weeks and everything went the way the site describes. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. Platform choice is decent — MT4, MT5 and a web option. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Took the one-phase account and it was a clean process start to finish. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. No regrets so far.
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Had a couple of minor platform hiccups but nothing account-ending. Would sign up for another account.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Every ticket I opened got a real answer in under a day. Happy to keep trading here.
Took the one-phase account and it was a clean process start to finish. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Discord community and support were genuinely helpful. No regrets so far.
I've been trading a SurgeTrader account for a couple of months and it's been a mixed bag. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. Took four days to get a straight answer about my account status. Ran it on MT5 and execution was fine for my style. Do your own research before you buy a challenge.
The challenge was fine — the problems started once I was funded. First withdrawal was fine, the second one they kept asking for more documents. Platform choice is decent — MT4, MT5 and a web option. Can't recommend based on my experience.
Took the one-phase account and it was a clean process start to finish. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. The daily and max drawdown rules are clearly shown on the dashboard in real time. Had a couple of minor platform hiccups but nothing account-ending. Happy to keep trading here.
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. The daily and max drawdown rules are clearly shown on the dashboard in real time. Had a couple of minor platform hiccups but nothing account-ending. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. No regrets so far.
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Every ticket I opened got a real answer in under a day. Would sign up for another account.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. Spreads and commissions were about average for a prop account. No regrets so far.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. Payout in USDT was processed faster than I expected. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Ran it on MT5 and execution was fine for my style. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. No regrets so far.
Traded a SurgeTrader account through the challenge and into funded without issues. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Every ticket I opened got a real answer in under a day. No regrets so far.
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Had a couple of minor platform hiccups but nothing account-ending. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Took the one-phase account and it was a clean process start to finish. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Platform choice is decent — MT4, MT5 and a web option. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Overall it works, but there are things I'd want to know beforehand. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. News-trading restrictions are stricter than the marketing suggests. Do your own research before you buy a challenge.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Platform choice is decent — MT4, MT5 and a web option. No regrets so far.
Traded a SurgeTrader account through the challenge and into funded without issues. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. The daily and max drawdown rules are clearly shown on the dashboard in real time. Happy to keep trading here.
Cleared the evaluation with SurgeTrader in a few weeks and everything went the way the site describes. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. Platform choice is decent — MT4, MT5 and a web option. Every ticket I opened got a real answer in under a day. Recommended if you actually follow the rules.
Been funded with SurgeTrader since earlier this year and it's been steady. Payout in USDT was processed faster than I expected. No surprise rules — the consistency and news-trading policy are spelled out up front. Discord community and support were genuinely helpful. Happy to keep trading here.
Signed up for the two-step challenge and passed on the second attempt. Two withdrawals so far, both paid within the stated window with no back-and-forth. The daily and max drawdown rules are clearly shown on the dashboard in real time. Spreads and commissions were about average for a prop account. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. No regrets so far.
Passed the challenge but the ride wasn't as smooth as I expected. Requested a withdrawal on a Monday and it was settled by Wednesday. The trailing drawdown calculation is not what I assumed and it cost me the account. Do your own research before you buy a challenge.
Traded a SurgeTrader account through the challenge and into funded without issues. My first payout was approved in about two days and hit my wallet the same week. Scaling plan is realistic and the profit split was exactly what was advertised. Support answered a KYC question over live chat within the hour. Happy to keep trading here.
SurgeTrader is an active proprietary trading firm listed on the TraderMarket leaderboard, currently ranked #17. Trader reviews on this page average 3.8 out of 5 across 35 submissions. A rating is not a guarantee — verify SurgeTrader's payout proof, terms, and track record before buying a challenge.
Each review is a 1–5 star rating left by a site visitor who traded with SurgeTrader. The headline score is the mean of all 35 published reviews and updates automatically as new ones are submitted.
Yes. Use the form on this page to submit a first-hand rating of the SurgeTrader evaluation, payouts, rules, or support. Reviews are public, permanent, and publish immediately.
No. Review scores reflect individual trader experience, not independent due diligence, and TraderMarket leaderboard position is paid rather than earned. Use reviews as one signal alongside payout history and the firm's own terms.
Continuously. The page re-checks for new reviews about once a minute, so the rating and the list stay current.
First-hand experience only. Your review publishes immediately and stays public.